Means of criminalistic tactics: concept and system
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.35774/app2020.02.166Keywords:
criminalistic tactics, means of criminalistic tactics, innovations in criminalistic tactics, limits of application of criminalistic tactics, new means of criminalistic tacticsAbstract
The article is devoted to the study of current problems of criminalistic tactics, their concept and system. The modern tendencies and scientific approaches in criminalistics devoted to research of means of criminalistic tactics are analyzed. The modern understanding of the concept of means of criminalistic tactics is considered, its definition taking into account traditional and innovative approaches in criminalistic science is offered. It is noted that the concept of "means of criminalistic tactics", which is used today in criminalistics, is collective and generalizing, reflecting the complexity and versatility of the development and use of means to achieve the objectives of investigation and trial. The main innovative directions of research and problems of use of means of criminalistic tactics in law enforcement activity which provide its efficiency and effectiveness are defined. The interrelation of means of criminalistic tactics with practice, modern achievements of science and technology, tendencies of development of criminalistics and other sciences is traced, their innovative character is noted.
It`s substantiated that one of the most important tasks of further development of criminalistics is to improve the existing system of criminalistic tactics in view of the emergence, development and current state of some innovative areas of criminalistics and expand the application of criminalistic tactics in various legal practices (investigative, judicial, prosecutorial, lawyer, search, detective, etc.). Research of new means of criminalistic tactics largely determines the innovative directions of modern criminalistic research in this field of knowledge. The use of criminalistic tactics should cover all types of activities, taking into account the trend of integration of scientific knowledge, application and implementation of interdisciplinary research and their further active use in legal practice.
It is noted that further development requires the study of traditional and new means of criminalistic tactics such as: tactical admission; tactical recommendation; tactical combination; tactics of investigative (search) action; tactics of unspoken investigative (search) action; tactics of judicial action; tactics of organizing and conducting tactical operations, etc. Means of criminalistic tactics that are actually real used and potentially designed to achieve the objectives of criminal justice form a “tactical arsenal” of investigator, detective, prosecutor, operatives, lawyer, judge (court), which allows them to successfully solve tactical problems that arise at each stage criminal proceedings, taking into account the peculiarities of the event being investigated or considered in court, investigative and judicial situations, determinant factors influencing the choice and expediency of the use of certain types of tactical means or their system, etc. The system and main functions of criminalistic tactics, scientific approaches and proposals for solving the researched problems are formulated, innovative directions of development are determined.References
Astashkina, E. N., Marochkin, N.A., Mikhalchuk, A. E. & Reshetnikov, V.Y. (2003). Rassledovanie prestuplenij. Kriminalisticheskie kompleksy. Navchalnij posibnik Crimes Investigation. Criminalistic Complexes. Study Guide, 3. Moscow: Prior-izdat in Russian.
Baev, O. Ya. (2011). Izbrannye raboty Selected works, 1-2, 216-236. Voronezh: Izdatelstvo Voronezhskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta in Russian.
Baev, O. Ya. (1977). Kriminalisticheskaya taktika i ugolovno-procesualnyj zakon Forensic tactics and criminal procedure law, 18. Voronezh in Russian.
Bahin, V. P. (1999 . Ponyatie, sushnost i soderzhanie kriminalisticheskoj taktiki. Lekciya Concept, essence and content of forensic tactics. Lecture], 17. Simferopol: Tavricheskij ekologicheskij institut in Ukrainian.
Bilenchuk, P. D., Lisichenko, V. K., Klimenko, N. I. & others (2001). Kriminalistika: Pidruchnik Criminalistics. Textbook. (2nd ed., rev.) Kyiv: Atika in Ukrainian.
Pryahin, Ye. V. (Eds.), Blaguta, R. I., Sibirna, R. I., Baranyak, V. M. & others. (2012). Kriminalistika. Navchalnij posibnik Criminalistics. Study Guide , 147-155). Kyiv: Atika in Ukrainian.
Belkin, R. S. (2001). Kriminalistika: problemy segodnyashnego dnya. Zlobodnevnye voprosy rossijskoj kriminalistiki Criminalistics: problems of today. Topical issues of Russian criminalistic, 17, 68-91. Moscow: NORMA-INFRA-M in Russian.
Belkin, R. S. (1997). Kurs kriminalistiki T. 1: Obshaya teoriya kriminalistiki. Criminalistics course. Volume 1: General theory of criminalistic, 1-3, 275-277. Moscow: Yurist in Russian.
Bernaz, P.V. (2015). Innovaciyi – osnova kriminalistichnogo zabezpechennya diyalnosti z rozsliduvannya zlochiniv Innovation – the basis of forensic support for crime investigation activities. Pivdennoukrayinskij pravnichij chasopis – South-Ukrainian Law Bulletin, 4, 49-53. in Ukrainian.
Vilgushinskij, M.J. (2011). Taktika sudovogo slidstva v sistemi kriminalistiki : avtoref. dis. … kand. yurid. nauk : 12.00.09. Tactics of judicial investigation in the system of criminalistics: abstract of the dissertation of the candidate of legal Sciences: 12.00.09, 6-7. Kharkov in Ukrainian.
Busel, V. T. (Eds.). (2005). Velikij tlumachnij slovnik suchasnoyi ukrayinskoyi movi Large explanatory dictionary of the modern Ukrainian language, 329. Kyiv: Iprin: VTF «Perun» in Ukrainian.
Gross, H. (1902). Gesammelte Kriminalistische Aufsätze Collected Criminalistic Essays, I. VIII, 432. Leipzig: F. C. W. Vogel in German.
Goncharenko, V.I. (1984). Nauchno-tehnicheskie sredstva v sledstvennoj praktike Scientific and technical means in investigative practice, 7-10. Kyiv in Ukrainian.
Grishko, I.K. (2020). Rol taktichnih zasobiv rozsliduvannya u protidiyi zlochinnosti. Kriminalistichni ta psihologichni aspekti dosudovogo rozsliduvannya: materiali naukovo-praktichnoyi internet-konferenciyi (29 kvitnya, 2020 r., m. Odesa) The role of tactical investigative tools in countering crime. Criminalistic and psychological aspects of preliminary investigation: materials of scientific and practical Internet conference (April 29, 2020, Odessa), 13-14, 15. Odesa: ODUVS in Ukrainian.
Golovin, A. Yu. & Yablokov, N. P. (Eds.). (2002). Kriminalisticheskaya sistematika Forensic systematics, 215. Moscow: LeksEkst in Russian.
Zhuravel, V.A. (2009). Sistemy slidchih dij ta taktichni operaciyi v strukturi okremoyi kriminalistichnoyi metodiki rozsliduvannya zlochiniv Systems of investigative actions and tactical operations in the structure of a separate forensic methodology for investigating crimes. Visnik akademiyi pravovyh nauk Ukrainy – Bulletin of Academy of Law Sciences of Ukraine, 2(57), 197-208 in Ukrainian.
Kapustina, M.V. (2016, 2018). Zabezpechennya kriminalistichne Forensic support.Velika ukrayinska yuridichna enciklopediya, 1-20. Kharkiv : Pravo. Vol. 20: Kriminalistika, sudova ekspertiza, yuridichna psihologiya. (V.Yu. Shepitko (Ed.) and others.) : Nac. akad. prav. nauk Ukrayini; In-t derzhavi ta prava im. V.M. Koreckogo NAN Ukrayini; Nac. yurid. un-t im. Yaroslava Mudrogo, 284-285 in Ukrainian.
Knyazkov, A.S. (2013). Analiticheskie taktiko-kriminalisticheskie sredstva dosudebnogo proizvodstva: monografiya Analytical tactical and forensic means of pre-trial production: monograph, 9-14. Tomsk: Izdatelstvo Tomskogo Universiteta in Russian.
Knyazkov, A.S. (2012). Klassifikacii takticheskih priemov kak «problemnoe pole» kriminalisticheskoj taktiki Classification of tactical techniques as a" problem field" of criminalistic tactics, Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta – Bulletin of Tomsk State University, 3(5), 39-57. in Russian.
Kogutich, I.I. (2008). Kriminalistika. Kurs lekcii Criminalistics. Course of lectures, 297-298. Kyiv: Atika in Ukrainian.
Kogutich, I.I. (2013). Tendenciyi pristosuvannya kriminalistichnih znan u zdijsnenni sudochinstva Trends in the adaptation of forensic knowledge in the implementation of legal proceedings. Visnik Lvivskogo universitetu. Seriia yurydychna – Bulletin of Lviv University. A legal series, 57, 336-341, 338- 339 in Ukrainian.
Shepitko, V. Yu. (Eds.), Konovalova, V. O. & Zhuravel, V. A. and other. (2008). Kriminalistika. Pidruchnik Criminalistics. Textbook, 4-th ed., rev., 133. Kharkiv: Pravo in Ukrainian.
Pyaskovskii, V. V., Chornous, Yu. M., Ishenko, A. V. & Alyeksyeyev, O. O. and other (2015). Kriminalistika. Pidruchnik Criminalistics. Textbook, 288. Kyiv: Center for educational literature in Ukrainian.
Tishenko, V.V. (Eds.). (2017). Kriminalistika. Pidruchnik Criminalistics. Textbook, 243-246. Odessa: Vidavnichij dim «Gelvetika» in Ukrainian.
Kuzmichov, V.S. & Prokopenko, G.I. (2001). Kriminalistika: navch. posibnik. Criminalistics. Textbook, 184. Kiyiv: Yurinkom Inter in Ukrainian.
Lozovskii, D.N. (2010). Metody rassledovaniya prestuplenij: monografiya Methods of crime investigation: monograph, 70. Moscow:Yurlitinform in Russian.
Saltevskii, M.V. (1998). Sredstva kriminalisticheskoj taktiki (metodologicheskij aspekt) Tools of criminalistic tactics (methodological aspect). Visnik Luganskogo institutu vnutrishnih sprav MVS Ukrayiny – Bulletin of Luhansk Institute of Internal Affairs of MIA of Ukraine, 1, 148-159 in Ukrainian.
Udovenko, Zh.V. & Galan, V.I.(Eds.). (2016). Kriminalistika Konspekt lekcij. Criminalistics. Lecture notes, 133. Kyiv: Center for educational literature in Ukrainian.
Fedorov, G.V. & Grigorovich, V.L. (2012). Innovacionnye napravleniya razvitiya kriminalistiki: monografiya Innovative directions of development of criminalistics: monograph, 7. Moscow:Yurlitinform in Russian.
Cheburenkov, A.A. (2010). Osnovy teorii rassledovaniya. Monografiya. Fundamentals of investigation theory. Monograf. (Pp.59-68). Moscow:Yurlitinform in Russian.
Shevchuk, V. M. (2014). Rol taktichnih zasobiv u protidiyi zlochinnosti The role of tactical means in countering crime. Pravova derzhava: istoriya, suchasnist ta perspektivi formuvannya v Ukrayini : materiali mizhnar. nauk.-prakt. konf. (m. Uzhgorod, 28 lyut. – 1 berez. 2014) Legal state: history, modernity and prospects of formation in Ukraine: materials of international science-practical Conf. (m. Uzhgorod, February 28-March 1, 2014) , 190-193. Kherson in Ukrainian.
Shevchuk, V. M. (2013). Taktichni operaciyi u kriminalistici: teoretichni zasadi formuvannya ta praktika realizaciyi: monografiia Tactical operations in criminology: theoretical foundations of formation and practice of implementation: monograph. Kharkov: «Apostil» in Ukrainian.
Shepitko, V. Yu. (2008). Zasobi kriminalistichnoyi taktiki v diyalnosti organiv dosudovogo slidstva (problemi efektivnosti zastosuvannya). Means of forensic tactics in the activities of pre-trial investigation bodies (problems of effectiveness of their use). Pravovi zasadi pidvishennya efektivnosti borotbi zi zlochinnistyu v Ukrayini : materiali nauk. konf., 15 trav. 2008 Legal basis for improving the effectiveness of crime control in Ukraine: proceedings of the scientific conference, may 15, 2008, 172-174, 174. Kharkov in Ukrainian.
Shepitko, V.Yu. (2007). Kriminalistichna taktika (sistemno-strukturnij analiz): monografiya Criminalistic tactics (system-structural analysis): monograph, 3. Kharkov: Kharkov legal in Ukrainian.
Shepitko, V.Yu. (2019). Innovaciyi v kriminalistici yak vidzerkalennya rozvitku nauki Innovations in criminology as a reflection of the development of science. Innovacijni metodi ta cifrovi tehnologiyi v kriminalistici, sudovij ekspertizi ta yuridichnij praktici : materiali mizhnar. «kruglogo stolu» (Kharkov, 12 grud. 2019) Innovative methods and digital technologies in criminology, forensic expertise and legal practice: materials of the international "round table" (Kharkov, December 12, 2019). NDI vivchennya problem zlochinnosti imeni akademika V. V. Stashisa NAPrN Ukrayini, 147-150). Kharkov: Pravo in Ukrainian.
Shepitko, V.Yu. & Zhuravel, V.A. (2009). Organizacijno-taktichni zasobi: ponyattya ta znachennya Organizational and tactical tools: concept and meaning. Pitannya borotbi zi zlochinnistyu – Questions of the the fight against crime, 18, 187. Kharkov in Ukrainian.
Yakushin, S.Yu. (2010a). Takticheskie resheniya sledovatelya i sredstva ih realizacii pri rassledovanii prestuplenij: ishodnye polozheniya chastnoj kriminalisticheskoj teorii Tactical decisions of the investigator and means of their implementation in the investigation of crimes: starting points of private criminalistic theory. Uchenye zapiski Kazanskogo universiteta. Seriya Gumanitarnye nauki Scientific notes of Kazan University. Series of Humanitarian Sciences, 150 (5), 237-244 in Russian.
Yakushin, S.Yu. (2010b). Takticheskie zadachi pri rassledovanii prestuplenij: ponyatie i vidy Tactical tasks in the investigation of crimes: the concept and types. Uchenye zapiski Kazanskogo universiteta. Seriya Gumanitarnye nauki – Scientific notes of Kazan University. Series of Humanitarian Sciences, 152 (4), 204-205 in Russian.
