International technical assistance under martial law: bureaucratic obstacles and opportunities for reform
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.35774/app2025.01.030Keywords:
international technical assistance, martial law, bureaucratic obstacles, reform, defense capability, legal regulationAbstract
The article examines the current state of attraction and utilization of international technical assistance (hereinafter – ITA) in Ukraine under martial law conditions caused by Russia’s aggression, ongoing since 2014, and the full-scale invasion in 2022. ITA is considered a key instrument for supporting defense capabilities, economic stability, and preparation for post-war reconstruction, encompassing financial resources, military equipment, technologies, and humanitarian aid.
Special attention is devoted to analyzing bureaucratic obstacles that reduce ITA effectiveness, including terminological inconsistencies between ITA and international military assistance (hereinafter – IMA), discrepancies in the regulatory framework, complexities in registration and accreditation procedures, insufficient oversight and monitoring, and limited coordination with development partners. The research methods include a dialectical approach to identify contradictions, a systemic-structural analysis of the ITA system, a comparative method to juxtapose international experiences, and an analysis of regulatory acts such as the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine Resolution No. 153 of February 15, 2002, «On the Creation of a Unified System for the Attraction, Use, and Monitoring of International Technical Assistance» (hereinafter – Resolution No. 153), and the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine Resolution No. 168 of February 13, 2024, «On Approval of the Procedure for Organizing Interaction of Central Executive Bodies and Other State Bodies Regarding the Attraction, Receipt, Transfer, Accounting, Monitoring, and Control of the Use of International Military Assistance to Meet the Needs of Security and Defense Forces During Martial Law» (hereinafter – Resolution No. 168).
The findings indicate that the current ITA attraction system does not meet wartime challenges: multi-stage procedures, such as project registration with the Secretariat of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine, can take weeks, critically affecting the timeliness of arms supplies. Terminological confusion between ITA and IMA significantly complicates coordination. A comprehensive reform is proposed: harmonization of the regulatory framework by integrating Resolutions No. 153 and No. 168, simplification of the registration procedure to 3–5 days, introduction of an electronic portal, development of unified control criteria, and establishment of a sectoral working group involving donors. The adaptation of international standards to Ukrainian realities is discussed, exemplified by the Paris Declaration. The results underscore the necessity of political will to implement reforms that would contribute to victory in the war and the country’s reconstruction.
References
Sampir, O. & Horbachova, Ya. (2024). Okremi pytannia doslidzhennia ozbroiennia, otrymanoho v ramkakh mizhnarodnoi tekhnichnoi dopomohy [Specific issues in the study of armaments obtained through international technical assistance]. Grail of Science, (36), 142–144. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.36074/grail-of-science.16.02.2024.020 [in Ukrainian]
Zinchuk, A. M. (2023). Okremi aspekty vstanovlennia i rozvytku mizhnarodnoi dopomohy dlia Ukrainy [Certain aspects of the establishment and development of international aid for Ukraine]. Mizhnarodnyi naukovyi zhurnal «Internauka» - International scientific journal «Internauka», 14 [in Ukrainian]
Duhinets, H. & Nizheiko, K. (2022). Mizhnarodna tekhnichna dopomoha v povojennii vidbudovi Ukrainy [International technical assistance in the post-war reconstruction of Ukraine]. Scientia Fructuosa, 143(3), 36-49 [in Ukrainian]
Horobets, N. S. (2024). Kliuchovi poniattia mizhnarodnoi viiskovoi dopomohy u sferi bezpeky i oborony Ukrainy [Key concepts of international military assistance in the field of security and defense of Ukraine]. Naukovyi visnyk Sivershchyny. Seriia: Pravo - Scientific Bulletin of the Seversk Region. Series: Law, 1 (21), C. 18-28 [in Ukrainian].
Svirko, S. V., Moroz, Yu. Yu., Vlasiuk, T. O., Dovhaliuk, V. V. & Sydorenko, O. P. (2023). Mekhanizm koordynatsii mizhnarodnoi tekhnichnoi dopomohy v konteksti pidtrymky ta vidbudovy oboronnoi ekonomiky Ukrainy [Mechanism for coordinating international technical assistance in the context of supporting and rebuilding Ukraine’s defense economy]. Akademichni vizii - Academic vision, (24) [in Ukrainian]
Svirko, S., Dovhaliuk, V., Kuchmenko, V., Trostenyuk, T., & Sydorenko, O. (2024). Orhanizatsiia zaluchennia, vykorystannia ta monitorynhu mizhnarodnoi tekhnichnoi dopomohy u sferi oborony [Organization of attraction, use, and monitoring of international technical assistance in the defense sector]. Heopolityka Ukrainy: istoriia i suchasnist - Geopolitics of Ukraine: history and present, (1(32)), 253–275 [in Ukrainian]
Demianiuk, O. (2022). Mizhnarodna tekhnichna dopomoha Ukraini yak instrument mizhnarodnoho spivrobitnytstva [International technical assistance to Ukraine as a tool of international cooperation]. Innovatsiini protsesy ekonomichnoho ta sotsialno-kulturnoho rozvytku: vitchyznianyi ta zarubizhnyi dosvid : tezy dop. KhV Mizhnar. nauk.-prakt. konf. molod. uchenykh i stud. [Ternopil, 29-30 berez. 2022 r.] - Innovative processes of economic and socio-cultural development: domestic and foreign experience: theses of the supplement of the 15th International Scientific-Practical Conference of Young Scientists and Students [Ternopil, March 29-30, 2022]. Ternopil: ZUNU, 27-29 [in Ukrainian].
Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine. (2024). Postanova № 168 vid 13 liutoho 2024 roku: Pro zatverdzhennia poriadku orhanizatsii vzaiemodii tsentralnykh orhaniv vykonavchoi vlady shchodo zaluchennia i vykorystannia mizhnarodnoi viiskovoi dopomohy [Resolution No. 168 of February 13, 2024: On approval of the procedure for organizing interaction of central executive authorities regarding the attraction and use of international military assistance]. Retrieved from https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/168-2024-п [in Ukrainian]
Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine. (2002). Postanova № 153 vid 15 liutoho 2002 roku: Pro stvorennia yedynoi systemy zaluchennia, vykorystannia ta monitorynhu mizhnarodnoi tekhnichnoi dopomohy [Resolution No. 153 of February 15, 2002: On the creation of a unified system for the attraction, use, and monitoring of international technical assistance]. Retrieved from https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/153-2002-п [in Ukrainian]
Ministry of Defense of Ukraine. (2018). Nakaz № 37 vid 1 liutoho 2018 roku: Pro zatverdzhennia instruktsii z orhanizatsii zaluchennia, vykorystannia, obliku ta monitorynhu mizhnarodnoi tekhnichnoi dopomohy [Order No. 37 of February 1, 2018: On approval of the instruction on the organization of attraction, use, accounting, and monitoring of international technical assistance]. Retrieved from https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/z0222-18 [in Ukrainian]
Larikova, T. V. (2022). Oblikovo-analitychne zabezpechennia zaluchennia ta vykorystannia mizhnarodnoi tekhnichnoi dopomohy rozporiadnykamy biudzhetnykh koshtiv [Accounting and analytical support for the attraction and use of international technical assistance by budget administrators]. Finansy Ukrainy - Finance of Ukraine, 11, 79–94 [in Ukrainian]
OECD. (2005). Paryzka deklaratsiia pro efektyvnist dopomohy [Paris Declaration on Aid Effectiveness]. Retrieved from https://www.oecd.org/dac/effectiveness/34428351.pdf [in Ukrainian]
NATO. (2022). Protsedury reahuvannia na kryzy ta humanitarna dopomoha [Crisis response procedures and humanitarian assistance]. URL: https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/topics_192000.htm [in Ukrainian]
Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Poland. (n.d.). Polska dopomoha: Humanitarna dopomoha [Polish aid: Humanitarian assistance]. Retrieved from https://www.gov.pl/web/polishaid/humanitarian-aid [in Ukrainian]
Loishyn, A., Yasenko, S., Kosaretskyi, Ye., & Boiko, R. (2022). Sutnist kliuchovykh poniat u sferi mizhnarodnoi dopomohy, nadanoi dlia zmitsnennia oborozdatnosti Ukrainy [The essence of key concepts in the field of international assistance provided to strengthen Ukraine’s defense capability]. Zbirnyk naukovykh prats Tsentru voienno-stratehichnykh doslidzhen NUOU imeni Ivana Cherniakhovskoho - Collection of scientific papers of the Center for Military and Strategic Studies of the Ivan Chernyakhovsky National University of Economics, 46–57 [in Ukrainian]