Decentralisation and the right to self-determination: an ethical perspective on crimean tatar autonomy
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.35774/app2025.02.031Keywords:
autonomy, indigenous peoples, Crimean Tatars, European Court of Human Rights, cultural identity, legal subjectivity, ethical responsibilityAbstract
The article analyses the legal positions of the European Court of Human Rights regarding the recognition of indigenous peoples’ rights to preserve and develop their own identity within a democratic state. The article substantiates the necessity of integrating an ethical dimension into national law-making, particularly in the development of autonomy models for the Crimean Tatar people as an autochthonous community of Ukraine. It is emphasised that the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights in cases concerning the cultural, linguistic, and religious rights of minorities contribute to a unified understanding of autonomy not merely as a territorial or administrative concept, but as a legal mechanism for safeguarding collective dignity, historical memory, and cultural identity. Attention is drawn to the fact that the Court’s case law formulates principles of fundamental importance for the States Parties to the Convention, according to which the state’s obligation is not limited to refraining from discriminatory actions, but also entails taking active measures to create conditions in which national minorities and indigenous peoples can effectively exercise their right to collective existence. The necessity of implementing these approaches within the national system of public governance is underlined, particularly in the context of ongoing de-occupation and the reconstruction of institutional interaction in the territory of Crimea. In this context, the Crimean Tatar issue emerges as a litmus test for the maturity of Ukrainian statehood and its ability to harmonise the legal and moral foundations of a modern democratic order. The conclusion is substantiated that the implementation of the autonomous rights of the Crimean Tatar people should be based not only on historical justice but also on established standards of international law confirmed by the jurisprudence of the European Court of Human Rights, which recognise the special status of indigenous peoples within a state, provided that the principles of territorial integrity, non-discrimination, and cultural pluralism are upheld. Such approach makes it possible to understand autonomy as an effective legal tool not for separation, but rather for affirming unity through diversity, in which each community has the right to development, self-realisation and symbolic recognition.
References
1. Krymska platforma [Crimea Platform]. Retrieved from https://crimea-platform.org/ [in Ukrainian] (accessed: 23.06.2025).
2. Havryliuk O. M. (2023). Krymski tatary yak korinnyi narod Ukrainy: pravovi aspekty ta perspektyvy avtonomii [The Crimean Tatars as an Indigenous People of Ukraine: Legal Aspects and Autonomy Prospects]. Naukovyi visnyk Uzhhorodskoho natsionalnoho universytetu. Seriia: Pravo – Scientific Bulletin of Uzhhorod National University. Law Series, 75, 123–128 [in Ukrainian].
3. Serhiichuk V. I. (2021). Deportatsiia krymskykh tatar 1944 roku: istorychni ta pravovi naslidky [The Deportation of the Crimean Tatars in 1944: Historical and Legal Consequences]. Ukrainskyi istorychnyi zhurnal – Ukrainian Historical Journal, 3, 45–58 [in Ukrainian].
4. Boiko O. V. (2024). Avtonomiia krymskykh tatar: konstitutsiino-pravovi zasady ta mizhnarodnyi dosvid [Autonomy of the Crimean Tatars: Constitutional Legal Framework and International Experience]. Pravo Ukrainy – Law of Ukraine, 1, 78–85 [in Ukrainian].
5. Spetsialna dopovid shchodo natsionalnykh menshyn [Special Report on National Minorities]. Retrieved from https://mvs.gov.ua/upload/2/0/1/5/2/4/specialna-dopovid-nacmensini.pdf [in Ukrainian] (accessed: 23.06.2025).
6. Bolotnyi Yu. I. (n.d.). Prava korinnykh narodiv Ukrainy yak tsentralnyi element yikh pravovoho statusu [The Rights of Indigenous Peoples of Ukraine as a Central Element of Their Legal Status]. Retrieved from http://apie.org.ua/uk/prava-kor%D1%96nnih-narod%D1%96v-ukra%D1%97ni-yak-cen/ [in Ukrainian] (accessed: 23.06.2025).
7. Mamchur A. V. (2023). Etychni aspekty polityky shchodo krymskotatarskoho narodu v konteksti deokupatsii Krymu [Ethical Aspects of Policy Regarding the Crimean Tatar People in the Context of Crimea's Deoccupation]. Filosofski obrii – Philosophical Horizons, 49, 67–75 [in Ukrainian].
8. Deklaratsiia OON pro prava korinnykh narodiv: ofitsiinyi tekst [UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples: Official Text]. (2007). Retrieved from https://www.un.org/development/desa/indigenouspeoples/declaration-on-the-rights-of-indigenous-peoples.html [in Ukrainian] (accessed: 17.05.2025).
9. Hromadianske suspilstvo Ukrainy: suchasni praktyky ta vyklyky rozvytku [Civil Society of Ukraine: Current Practices and Development Challenges]. (2018). V. M. Yablonskyi (Ed.), O. A. Korniievskyi, Yu. A. Tyshchenko et al. Kyiv: NISD. 126 p. [in Ukrainian].
10. Kovalchuk I. V. (2024). Balans mizh intehratsiieiu ta zberezhenniam identychnosti korinnykh narodiv: etychni ta pravovi dylemy [Balancing Integration and Preservation of Indigenous Identity: Ethical and Legal Dilemmas]. Visnyk Kyivskoho natsionalnoho universytetu im. Tarasa Shevchenka. Yurydychni nauky – Bulletin of Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv. Legal Studies, 1, 89–95 [in Ukrainian].
11. Etrenko D. O. (2023). Rol mizhkulturnoho dialohu u formuvanni inkliuzyvnoho suspilstva v Ukraini [The Role of Intercultural Dialogue in Building an Inclusive Society in Ukraine]. Visnyk Natsionalnoi akademii derzhavnoho upravlinnia pry Prezydentovi Ukrainy. Seriia: Derzhavne upravlinnia – Bulletin of the National Academy of Public Administration under the President of Ukraine. Public Administration Series, 1, 45–53 [in Ukrainian].
12. Osvita dlia demokratychnoho hromadianstva ta osvita z prav liudyny [Education for Democratic Citizenship and Human Rights Education]. Retrieved from https://www.living-democracy.com/uk/about-edc-hre/ [in Ukrainian] (accessed: 23.06.2025).
13. Kultura polityka v Ukraini: analitychnyi ohliad [Cultural Policy in Ukraine: Analytical Overview]. (2007). O. Hrytsenko (Ed.). Kyiv: 160 p. [in Ukrainian].
14. Novikova I. M. (2023). Avtonomiia korinnykh narodiv yak instrument zberezhennia identychnosti ta yednosti derzhavy: filosofsko-pravovyi analiz [Autonomy of Indigenous Peoples as a Tool for Preserving Identity and State Unity: A Philosophical and Legal Analysis]. Visnyk Kharkivskoho natsionalnoho universytetu im. V. N. Karazina. Seriia: Pravo – Bulletin of V. N. Karazin Kharkiv National University. Law Series, 37, 101–108 [in Ukrainian].
15. Kornat L., Kornat O. (2021). Normatyvno-pravove zabezpechennia prav korinnykh narodiv: mizhnarodnyi dosvid ta ukrainski perspektyvy [Legal Support for the Rights of Indigenous Peoples: International Experience and Ukrainian Prospects]. Visnyk Lvivskoho universytetu. Seriia filosofsko-politolohichni studii – Bulletin of Lviv University. Philosophical and Political Science Series, 37, 161–169 [in Ukrainian].
16. Krainy svitu i Ukraina: entsyklopediia [Countries of the World and Ukraine: Encyclopedia]. (2018). Vol. 1: Pivnichna Yevropa. Zakhidna Yevropa. Pivdenna Yevropa [Northern, Western, and Southern Europe]. A. I. Kudriachenko (Chair), A. H. Bulvinskyi (Scientific Ed.), Instytut vsesvitnoi istorii NAN Ukrainy. Kyiv: Feniks. 564 p. [in Ukrainian].
17. Varunts L. D. (2018). Konstytutsiino-pravove stanovyshche korinnykh narodiv Kanady: problemni pytannia [The Constitutional and Legal Status of Indigenous Peoples in Canada: Problematic Issues]. Visnyk Kharkivskoho natsionalnoho universytetu im. V. N. Karazina. Seriia: Pravo – Bulletin of V. N. Karazin Kharkiv National University. Law Series, 25, 68–74 [in Ukrainian].
18. Dohovir Vaitanhy ta prava maori: istorychnyi ta suchasnyi aspekty [The Treaty of Waitangi and Maori Rights: Historical and Contemporary Aspects]. Mizhnarodni vidnosyny: teoretychni ta praktychni aspekty – International Relations: Theoretical and Practical Aspects, 11, 56–65 [in Ukrainian].
19. Natsionalni menshyny (spilnoty) i korinni narody v okupatsii: borotba za vyzhyvannia [National Minorities and Indigenous Peoples in Occupation: Struggle for Survival]. (2023). Ombudsman of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine. Kyiv. 32 p. [in Ukrainian].
20. Kaparulin Yu. V., Zadorozhnia O. V. (2024). Zakhyst prav korinnykh narodiv: mizhnarodni standarty ta dosvid Ukrainy [Protection of Indigenous Peoples' Rights: International Standards and Ukrainian Experience]. Naukovyi visnyk Khersonskoho derzhavnoho universytetu. Seriia: Yurydychni nauky – Scientific Bulletin of Kherson State University. Legal Sciences Series, 2, 48–54 [in Ukrainian].
21. Avtonomii: poniattia, klasyfikatsiia, pozytyvni ta nehatyvni naslidky utvorennia na dosvidi inozemnykh krain i sytuatsiia v Ukraini (chastyna I) [Autonomies: Concepts, Classifications, Positive and Negative Consequences of Formation Based on Foreign Experience and the Situation in Ukraine (Part I)]. Holos Krymu – Voice of Crimea. Retrieved from https://www.voicecrimea.com.ua/uk/analytics/post/avtonomi%D1%97-ponyattya-klasifikaciya-pozitivni-ta-negativni-naslidki-utvorennya-na-dosvidi-inozemnix-kra%D1%97n-i-situaciya-v-ukra%D1%97ni-chastina-i/ [in Ukrainian] (accessed: 23.06.2025).
22. Martseniuk O., Humenna O., Denhdobra T. (2023). Perspektyvy zmitsnennia finansovoi samodostatnosti terytorialnykh hromad v umovakh detsentralizatsii [Prospects for Strengthening the Financial Self-Sufficiency of Territorial Communities in the Context of Decentralization]. Ekonomika ta suspilstvo – Economy and Society, 51. Retrieved from https://economyandsociety.in.ua/index.php/journal/article/view/2505 [in Ukrainian] (accessed: 30.06.2025).
23. Rada Yevropy [Council of Europe]. (2020). Vplyv detsentralizatsii vlady na natsionalni menshyny v Ukraini v okremykh rehionakh: Chernivetskii, Odeskii i Zakarpatskii oblasty [The Impact of Decentralization of Power on National Minorities in Ukraine in Selected Regions: Chernivtsi, Odesa and Zakarpattia Oblasts]. October. 51 p. [in Ukrainian].
24. Natsionalnyi instytut stratehichnykh doslidzhen. (2016). Shchodo dotrymannia prav krymskotatarskoho narodu v aneksovanomu Krymu: analitychna zapyska [On Compliance with the Rights of the Crimean Tatar People in the Annexed Crimea: Analytical Note]. Retrieved from http://www.niss.gov.ua/articles/1798/ [in Ukrainian] (accessed: 23.06.2025).
25. Problemy zberezhennia krymskotatarskoi movy v suchasnomu konteksti [Problems of Preserving the Crimean Tatar Language in the Modern Context]. (2023). Movoznavstvo – Linguistics, 2, 78–86 [in Ukrainian].
26. Derzhavna sluzhba Ukrainy z etnopolityky ta svobody sovisti [State Service of Ukraine for Ethnic Policy and Freedom of Conscience]. (2025). Zberezhennia ta rozvytok mov natsionalnykh menshyn v Ukraini: kruhlyi stil do Mizhnarodnoho dnia ridnoi movy [Preservation and Development of the Languages of National Minorities in Ukraine: Round Table for International Mother Language Day]. Retrieved from https://dess.gov.ua/zberezhennia-ta-rozvytok-mov-natsionalnykh-menshyn-v-ukraini-kruhlyy-stil-do-mizhnarodnoho-dnia-ridnoi-movy/ [in Ukrainian] (accessed: 23.06.2025).
27. Babin B. V., Hrinenko O. O., Prykhodko A. V. (2019). Realizatsiia ta zakhyst prav korinnykh narodiv Ukrainy v suchasnykh umovakh: referat [Implementation and Protection of the Rights of Indigenous Peoples of Ukraine in Modern Conditions: Report]. Instytut zakonodavstva Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy. Kyiv. 7 p. [in Ukrainian].
28. Heneralna Asambleia OON [UN General Assembly]. (2023). Rezoliutsii shchodo sytuatsii z pravamy liudyny v Avtonomnii Respublitsi Krym ta misti Sevastopoli (Ukraina): ofitsiinyi tekst [Resolutions on the Human Rights Situation in the Autonomous Republic of Crimea and the City of Sevastopol (Ukraine): Official Text]. Retrieved from https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4033013 [in Ukrainian] (accessed: 23.06.2025).
29. Suspilne Krym. (2024). 11-y rik pid okupatsiieiu: YeS ukhvalyv rezoliutsiiu shchodo Krymu [11th Year of Occupation: EU Adopted a Resolution on Crimea]. Retrieved from https://suspilne.media/crimea/906535-11-j-rik-pid-okupacieu-es-uhvaliv-rezoluciu-sodo-krimu/ [in Ukrainian] (accessed: 23.06.2025).
30. Orhanizatsiia z bezpeky i spivrobitnytstva v Yevropi [OSCE]. (2023). Chetvertyi promizhnyi zvit shchodo porushen mizhnarodnoho humanitarnoho prava ta prav liudyny v Ukraini [Fourth Interim Report on Violations of International Humanitarian Law and Human Rights in Ukraine]. December. Retrieved from https://www.osce.org/files/f/documents/a/4/561457.pdf [in Ukrainian] (accessed: 23.06.2025).
31. Holos Krymu [Voice of Crimea]. (2024). Krymske pytannia v mizhnarodnykh rishenniakh: analiz ta shliakh do realizatsii v derzhavnii politytsi [The Crimean Issue in International Decisions: Analysis and the Path to Implementation in State Policy]. 12 November. Retrieved from https://www.voicecrimea.com.ua/uk/analytics/post/krimske-pitannya-v-mizhnarodnix-rishennyax-analiz-ta-shlyax-do-realizaci%D1%97-v-derzhavnij-politici/ [in Ukrainian] (accessed: 23.06.2025).
32. Nikolaienko S. V., Savchenko A. V., Yurkivska Yu. O., Duka T. P. (2023). Osoblyvosti vprovadzhennia inkliuzyvnoi osvity v Ukraini: vyklyky, stratehii ta perspektyvy rozvytku [Features of Inclusive Education Implementation in Ukraine: Challenges, Strategies and Development Prospects]. Problemy suchasnykh transformatsii. Seriia: Pedahohika ta psykholohiia – Problems of Modern Transformations. Series: Pedagogy and Psychology, 1(22), 60–67 [in Ukrainian].
33. Kultura spadshchyna krymskykh tatar yak element natsionalnoi pam'iati Ukrainy: zbirnyk naukovykh prats [The Cultural Heritage of the Crimean Tatars as an Element of Ukraine's National Memory: Collection of Scientific Papers]. (2022). Odesa: Pivdennoukrainskyi natsionalnyi pedahohichnyi universytet im. K. D. Ushynskoho. [in Ukrainian].
34. Dekolonializatsiia osvity v Ukraini: intehratsiia istorii korinnykh narodiv [Decolonization of Education in Ukraine: Integration of Indigenous Histories]. (2024). Ukrainska osvita – Ukrainian Education, 1, 12–20 [in Ukrainian].
35. Semkiv I. V. (2023). Formuvannia empatii ta krytychnoho myslennia v uchniv cherez vyvchennia istorii natsionalnykh menshyn [Formation of Empathy and Critical Thinking in Students through the Study of the History of National Minorities]. Osvitnii prostir Ukrainy. Seriia: Pedahohika – Educational Space of Ukraine. Series: Pedagogy, 2(1/25), 139–143 [in Ukrainian].
36. Shcherba O. (2011). Kulturno-osvitnia skladova diialnosti krymskotatarskoi spilnoty v Ukraini [Cultural and Educational Component of the Crimean Tatar Community's Activity in Ukraine]. Ukrainska natsionalna ideia: realii ta perspektyvy rozvytku – Ukrainian National Idea: Realities and Development Prospects, 23, 98–101 [in Ukrainian].
37. Festivaly krymskotatarskoi kultury yak instrument mizhkulturnoho dialohu [Crimean Tatar Culture Festivals as a Tool for Intercultural Dialogue]. (2023). Narodoznavchi zoshyty – Ethnology Notebooks, 6, 143–151 [in Ukrainian].
38. Kulyniak I. Ya., Karyi O. I., Prokopyshyn-Rashkevych L. M., Ohinok S. V., Bondarenko Yu. H. (2023). Yevropeiskyi dosvid popularizatsii istorychnoi spadshchyny ta kulturnoho turyzmu [European Experience of Promoting Historical Heritage and Cultural Tourism]. Lviv: Rastr-7. 254 p. [in Ukrainian].
39. Roli nezalezhnykh media u zberezhenni identychnosti korinnykh narodiv v umovakh konfliktu: analitychnyi ohliad [The Role of Independent Media in Preserving the Identity of Indigenous Peoples in Conflict Conditions: Analytical Review]. (2024). Kyiv: Instytut masovoi informatsii. [in Ukrainian].
40. Symvolichne vyznannia kulturnoho rozmaittia yak osnova natsionalnoi yednosti [Symbolic Recognition of Cultural Diversity as the Basis of National Unity]. (2023). Politychna dumka – Political Thought, 3, 29–37 [in Ukrainian].
41. Istorii Ukrainy: vidnovlennia pravdy [Histories of Ukraine: Restoring the Truth] [Electronic resource]. (2024, March 5). Hlavred. Retrieved from https://glavred.net/movies/istorii-ukrainy-vosstanovlenie-pravdy-na-1-1-ukraina-startuyut-vechera-dokumentalnyh-filmov-10464706.html [in Ukrainian] (accessed: 23.06.2025).
